Updated 30 September 2026 · SmartHomeCue Editorial Team
Lockly vs Vivint

Lockly
No. 7 of 72 in home security cameras9.1Best for: One maker for locks, cameras and video doorbells with nothing to pay monthly.
Vivint
No. 9 of 72 in home security cameras8.8Best for: A full home covered by a single monitored plan, installed for you.
Key differences
- Lockly scores higher overall: 9.1 against 8.8.
- Lockly has a lower price ($189.99 against $199.99).
- Among products, only Vivint offers Alarm and Smoke alarm.
- Among support channels, only Lockly offers Community and Email.
- Among ecosystems, only Lockly offers Alexa, HomeKit and Matter.
Side by side
Lockly | ||
|---|---|---|
| Cost | ||
| Price | $189.99Lower | $199.99 |
| Monitoring per month | $0 / monthat the median of 40 brands | $24.99 to $44.99 / monthin the highest quarter of 40 brands |
| Minimum contract | 0 months | up to 60 months |
| Cloud plan per month | $0 / monthbelow the median of 31 brands | Not listed |
| Offer | ||
| Products | Camera, Smart lock, Video doorbell | Alarm, Camera, Smart lock, Video doorbell, Smoke alarm |
| Professional monitoring | No | Yes |
| Local storage | Yes | Yes |
| Recording retention | 90 daysHigherin the highest quarter of 44 brands | 10 daysin the lowest quarter of 44 brands |
| Installation required | No | Yes |
| Money-back period | 30 days | 30 days |
| Other facts | ||
| Pricing model | DIY | Monitored |
| Free features | Free Lockly Home app with 90-day access logs, 3 eBadges and 3 OAC per month | Not listed |
| Top resolution | 2k | 4K |
| Power source | Battery, Solar | Wired, PoE |
| Ecosystems | Alexa, Google, HomeKit, Matter, SmartThings | |
| Company | ||
| Legal entity | Pin Genie Inc., doing business as Lockly | Vivint LLC |
| Headquarters | United States | United States |
| Founded | 2014 | Not listed |
| Support channels | Community, Email, Help centre, Phone | Phone, Help centre |
| Smart home devices | ||
| Device types | Hub | Hub, Sensor, Thermostat, Lighting, Plug |
| Price from | $169.99Lower | $199.99 |
| Protocols | Matter, Wi-Fi | Wi-Fi |
| Hub required | No | Yes |
| Local control | Yes | Yes |
| Heat pump compatible | No | Not listed |
| Energy reporting | No | Yes |
| Subscription per month | $0 / monthLower | $24.99 to $44.99 / month |
| Warranty | 1 to 5 yearsHigher | 1 year |
| Markets | United States | United States |
Part scores
Lockly
Our verdict on each
Lockly
Lockly suits homeowners and renters who want locks, cameras and video doorbells from one maker and prefer no monthly fee, with monitoring costing $0. The trade-off is upfront hardware, which sits above the entry gear at Annke and Aqara, and there is no contract to serve.
Read the full Lockly reviewVivint
Vivint suits households that want a monitored system sold, installed and maintained as a single package rather than a box of self installed cameras. It scores 8.8 overall, and the trade to weigh is a higher entry price and a contract term against professional monitoring on every device.
Read the full Vivint reviewIf neither fits
How they place
- Security cameras without a subscription
- Lockly 5 of 43 by score · Vivint 6 of 43 by score
- Video doorbells
- Lockly 8 of 47 by score · Vivint 12 of 47 by score
- Smart locks
- Lockly 6 of 32 by score · Vivint 10 of 32 by score
Pros and cons
Lockly
Pros
- Nothing recurs: monitoring costs $0, the cloud plan month is $0 and the Lockly Home subscription is $0.
- Contract months are 0 months, so there is no term to serve and hardware is the only outlay.
- Recordings stay on the device, since local storage is supported and history runs to 90 days.
Cons
- Professional monitoring is not offered, so anyone wanting an alarm response service has to look at a monitored alarm brand.
- Shipping is listed for US, so buyers elsewhere pay return postage or source from a reseller.
- The free Lockly Home app tier keeps a limited window of access records, 90 days, so a longer audit trail has to be stored by the household.
Vivint
Pros
- Professional monitoring is included rather than sold as an add on, and the plan also supports local storage with video kept for 10 days.
- A single plan spans alarm, camera and smart lock, so cameras, a video doorbell, a smart lock, an alarm and a smoke alarm run on the same account.
- The entry figure of $199.99 comes with a 30 days money back window and a 1 year warranty behind the hardware.
Cons
- The service sells in the US only, which closes it off for buyers in other countries.
- Support runs through phone and help centre only, so phone is the practical route when a hub or camera needs troubleshooting.
Who each suits
Lockly
Who it suits
- Renters and homeowners who want a lock, a camera and a video doorbell without a monthly bill.
- People in the US who want recordings held on local storage with local control in the app.
- Households already running alexa, google and homekit, since Lockly reaches all of those platforms over Matter and Wi-Fi.
Who should look elsewhere
- Anyone who wants an alarm response service, because professional monitoring is not offered and a monitored alarm specialist is the better route than a camera maker.
- Shoppers outside US, where Lockly does not ship direct and a local reseller sets the final price.
Vivint
Who it suits
- Households that want professional monitoring and installation handled rather than self installed.
- People fitting out a whole home at once, since one account covers alarm, camera and smart lock.
- Owners who already run Google in the home, as the range works with google.
Who should look elsewhere
- Buyers outside the US, where the service is not offered.
- Renters who may move during the term, because contract terms run up to 60 months.
Questions about each
Lockly
What does a Lockly system cost to run each month?
Lockly does not charge for the running side. Professional monitoring costs $0, the cloud plan month is $0 and the Lockly Home subscription is $0. The free app tier still carries access logs, guest badges and one-time access codes, so nothing in the basic setup is held back behind a plan.
What do Lockly locks and cameras cost to buy?
Smart locks start at $169.99, and a listed model sits at $189.99. Hardware is the main outlay here because there is no monthly plan to offset it. The warranty runs 1 to 5 years, and the return window is 30 days, which takes some of the risk out of a first order.
Vivint
What does a Vivint system cost to begin with?
The introductory figure for the Vivint security plan is $199.99. After that, the recurring monitoring charge is $24.99 to $44.99 a month, and installation is required, so the real outlay is the entry figure plus the monthly fee for as long as the system stays in the house. Contract terms run up to 60 months, which sets how long that addition continues.
Is there a contract, and how long does it run?
Contract terms run up to 60 months, spanning a short arrangement at one end and a multi year tie in at the other. That length decides how much of the $24.99 to $44.99 monitoring fee you pay in total, so the term matters more than the entry figure of $199.99 for anyone planning to move within a few years.
Sources
Lockly
- lockly.com: 19 facts, checked 30 September 2026
Vivint
- vivint.com: 16 facts, checked 30 September 2026





