Updated 30 September 2026 · SmartHomeCue Editorial Team
British Gas - Hive - Smart Home & Heating vs Ecobee
British Gas - Hive - Smart Home & Heating
No. 12 of 16 in smart thermostats8.8Best for: UK homes that want local heating control and a broad smart home range on a single hub.

Ecobee
No. 3 of 16 in smart thermostats8.8Best for: Heating-led homes in the United States and Canada that add a camera, video doorbell or alarm sensor to the same brand.
Key differences
- Ecobee has a longer warranty (3 years against 1 year).
- Among support channels, only British Gas - Hive - Smart Home & Heating offers Chat.
- Ecobee is available in 1 more country.
- Among device types, only British Gas - Hive - Smart Home & Heating offers Trv, Lighting and Plug.
- Among ecosystems, only Ecobee offers SmartThings.
Side by side
Ecobee | ||
|---|---|---|
| Cost | ||
| Price from | £14 | $139.99 |
| Subscription per month | £3.99 / month | $5 / month |
| Offer | ||
| Hub required | Yes | No |
| Local control | Yes | Not listed |
| Heat pump compatible | Yes | Not listed |
| Energy reporting | Yes | Yes |
| Warranty | 1 yearin the lowest quarter of 32 brands | 3 yearsHigherabove the median of 32 brands |
| Other facts | ||
| Device types | Thermostat, Trv, Lighting, Plug, Hub, Sensor | Thermostat, Sensor |
| Protocols | Zigbee, Wi-Fi | Not listed |
| Ecosystems | Alexa, Google, HomeKit | Alexa, Google, HomeKit, SmartThings |
| Markets | United Kingdom | United States, Canada |
| Company | ||
| Legal entity | Centrica Hive Limited | Ecobee Technologies ULC |
| Headquarters | United Kingdom | Canada |
| Founded | 2013 | 2007 |
| Support channels | Help centre, Chat, Phone | Phone, Help centre |
Part scores
British Gas - Hive - Smart Home & Heating
Our verdict on each
British Gas - Hive - Smart Home & Heating
Hive is the pick for UK households that want heating control which keeps working when the connection does not, with local control and a hub that also carries lighting, plugs and sensors. Entry hardware starts at £14, and Hive Plus adds £3.99 a month on top.
Read the full British Gas - Hive - Smart Home & Heating reviewEcobee
Ecobee suits homeowners who want heating handled properly and security added on the side, rather than a full alarm shop. Entry pricing starts at $139.99, close to the site entry median, and the thermostat warranty runs 3 years, with sales limited to the United States and Canada.
Read the full Ecobee reviewPros and cons
British Gas - Hive - Smart Home & Heating
Pros
- Local control keeps schedules and heating changes at the hub, and a hub is required for the range anyway, so the two fit together.
- Device types run thermostat, trv and lighting, so heating, lighting, plugs and sensors share one box instead of separate systems.
- Heat pump compatible, which suits a home replacing a boiler with a heat pump and keeping the same controls.
Cons
- Hive Plus costs £3.99 a month on top of hardware bought from £14, so the running cost is separate from the purchase.
- A single market: GB is the only region listed, so the range does not travel to other countries.
- Warranty cover runs 1 year, and a hub is required for everything else in the range, so that term matters more here than on a standalone device.
Ecobee
Pros
- No hub is required, so there is no extra box to buy, and energy reporting comes with the smart thermostats.
- The thermostat warranty runs 3 years, with a 30 day money back period behind the purchase.
- The thermostats and sensors work with alexa, google and homekit, so voice assistants, HomeKit and SmartThings homes are all covered.
Cons
- The security side is a running cost: the paid plan is $5 a month, and professional monitoring only sits on that tier.
- The video doorbell is wired, so it needs a cable run at the front door rather than a battery you swap yourself.
- Recorded video is kept for 30 days, a short window for reviewing anything older.
Who each suits
British Gas - Hive - Smart Home & Heating
Who it suits
- UK homes heated by radiators who want trv units added room by room on the same hub as the lighting.
- People who want voice control through alexa, google and homekit rather than a single vendor app.
- Households on an unreliable broadband line, since local control keeps schedules at the hub.
Who should look elsewhere
- Shoppers outside GB: the range is listed for that market only, so it does not cover other countries.
- Buyers who want radiator valves and blinds covered in the same ecosystem: Aqara lists hub, sensor and lighting without trv, while SONOFF covers thermostat, trv and lighting.
- People who want a lighting-first system: Lutron lists lighting, blinds and thermostat built around lighting and blinds, where thermostat, trv and lighting leads with heating and trv units.
Ecobee
Who it suits
- Buyers who want a thermostat as the anchor and a camera, video doorbell or alarm sensor added to the same brand later.
- Homes that already run alexa, google and homekit and want heating data in the same place as everything else.
- People who want professional monitoring without a long agreement, since the contract length is 0 months.
Who should look elsewhere
- Full home device shoppers, since Aqara’s range covers hub, sensor and lighting while ecobee’s device types are thermostat and sensor.
- Buyers chasing lighting and blinds control as the main event: Lutron’s device list runs lighting, blinds and thermostat, well beyond a heating brand.
- Budget builders who want a hub, heating valve and blinds under one roof, which is what SONOFF lists in thermostat, trv and lighting.
Current offers
British Gas - Hive - Smart Home & Heating
Not listed
Ecobee
Discount code
$20 off your next purchase with newsletter signup: $20 USD
New customers only; promotional code sent by email after form submit; cannot be combined with other offers; cannot apply to prior purchases
Source, checked 30 September 2026
Free trial
1 month free Smart Security + Professional Monitoring
Offered during system setup; no contracts, no credit card required; 24/7 pro monitoring not available in Calgary, AB
Source, checked 30 September 2026
Questions about each
British Gas - Hive - Smart Home & Heating
What does Hive cost to start with?
Entry hardware is priced from £14, which is the lowest figure in the range rather than the cost of a full heating setup. Anything above that, including a hub, sits higher. Hive Plus is a separate subscription at £3.99 a month on top of whatever hardware is bought.
Is there a monthly subscription for Hive Plus?
Hive Plus is listed at £3.99 a month. That is the running cost to weigh after the purchase, and it is separate from the £14 entry hardware price. Buyers who keep a system for years should read the monthly figure as the number that repeats, not the number on the box.
Ecobee
Do I have to pay a subscription to use the security devices?
There is a free Core plan that covers motion and person detection along with door or window open and close alerts, so the basics cost nothing to run. Paying $5 a month moves you onto the plan that adds professional monitoring and stored video history. The choice is how much of the security side you want switched on.
Is there a minimum contract on the ecobee security plan?
There is no minimum term here: the contract length on the security plans is 0 months, so you are not tied into a long agreement. You can stop the plan and keep the hardware. Professional monitoring is offered, and it runs in the United States and Canada.
Sources
British Gas - Hive - Smart Home & Heating
- hivehome.com: 15 facts, checked 30 September 2026
Ecobee
- ecobee.com: 12 facts, checked 30 September 2026


