Updated 30 September 2026 · SmartHomeCue Editorial Team
British Gas - Hive - Smart Home & Heating vs Shelly
British Gas - Hive - Smart Home & Heating
No. 12 of 16 in smart thermostats8.8Best for: UK homes that want local heating control and a broad smart home range on a single hub.
Shelly
No. 2 of 16 in smart thermostats9.1Best for: Broad smart home kit with no hub, no monthly plan and no contract.
Key differences
- Shelly scores higher overall: 9.1 against 8.8.
- Among support channels, only Shelly offers Email and Community.
- Shelly is available in 28 more countries.
- Among device types, only British Gas - Hive - Smart Home & Heating offers Trv.
- Among device types, only Shelly offers Blinds.
Side by side
| Cost | ||
|---|---|---|
| Price from | £14 | €12.90 |
| Subscription per month | £3.99 / month | €3.99 / month |
| Offer | ||
| Hub required | Yes | No |
| Local control | Yes | Yes |
| Heat pump compatible | Yes | Not listed |
| Energy reporting | Yes | Yes |
| Warranty | 1 yearin the lowest quarter of 32 brands | 2 to 5 yearsHigherin the highest quarter of 32 brands |
| Matter certified | Not listed | Yes |
| Other facts | ||
| Device types | Thermostat, Trv, Lighting, Plug, Hub, Sensor | Thermostat, Lighting, Plug, Hub, Sensor, Blinds |
| Protocols | Zigbee, Wi-Fi | Matter, Zigbee, Z wave, Wi-Fi |
| Ecosystems | Alexa, Google, HomeKit | Alexa, Google, HomeKit, Matter |
| Markets | United Kingdom | Austria, Australia, Belgium, Switzerland, Cyprus, Czechia+ 23 moreGermany, Denmark, Estonia, Spain, Finland, France, United Kingdom, Greece, Croatia, Hungary, Ireland, Italy, Latvia, Lithuania, Luxembourg, Netherlands, New Zealand, Poland, Portugal, Romania, Sweden, Slovenia, Slovakia |
| Company | ||
| Legal entity | Centrica Hive Limited | Shelly Europe Ltd |
| Headquarters | United Kingdom | Bulgaria |
| Founded | 2013 | Not listed |
| Support channels | Help centre, Chat, Phone | Email, Chat, Phone, Help centre, Community |
Part scores
British Gas - Hive - Smart Home & Heating
Our verdict on each
British Gas - Hive - Smart Home & Heating
Hive is the pick for UK households that want heating control which keeps working when the connection does not, with local control and a hub that also carries lighting, plugs and sensors. Entry hardware starts at £14, and Hive Plus adds £3.99 a month on top.
Read the full British Gas - Hive - Smart Home & Heating reviewShelly
Shelly suits homeowners and renters who want broad smart home kit with no hub to buy first. Device prices start at €12.90, the range covers thermostat, lighting, plug, hub, sensor and blinds work over matter, zigbee and z wave, and local control keeps routines running when the internet drops.
Read the full Shelly reviewPros and cons
British Gas - Hive - Smart Home & Heating
Pros
- Local control keeps schedules and heating changes at the hub, and a hub is required for the range anyway, so the two fit together.
- Device types run thermostat, trv and lighting, so heating, lighting, plugs and sensors share one box instead of separate systems.
- Heat pump compatible, which suits a home replacing a boiler with a heat pump and keeping the same controls.
Cons
- Hive Plus costs £3.99 a month on top of hardware bought from £14, so the running cost is separate from the purchase.
- A single market: GB is the only region listed, so the range does not travel to other countries.
- Warranty cover runs 1 year, and a hub is required for everything else in the range, so that term matters more here than on a standalone device.
Shelly
Pros
- A hub is not required, so plugs, sensors and switches start working without bridge hardware.
- Local control is supported and energy reporting comes as standard, so offline routines and consumption figures arrive together.
- The range covers thermostat, lighting and plug and works across alexa, google and homekit, with Matter certification on the relevant devices.
Cons
- Cloud retention of 30 days needs the Shelly Smart Control premium plan at €3.99 a month.
- The camera runs on battery and wired, so placement decides between wiring and battery changes.
- Returns close after 14 days, a short window to test a wide install.
Who each suits
British Gas - Hive - Smart Home & Heating
Who it suits
- UK homes heated by radiators who want trv units added room by room on the same hub as the lighting.
- People who want voice control through alexa, google and homekit rather than a single vendor app.
- Households on an unreliable broadband line, since local control keeps schedules at the hub.
Who should look elsewhere
- Shoppers outside GB: the range is listed for that market only, so it does not cover other countries.
- Buyers who want radiator valves and blinds covered in the same ecosystem: Aqara lists hub, sensor and lighting without trv, while SONOFF covers thermostat, trv and lighting.
- People who want a lighting-first system: Lutron lists lighting, blinds and thermostat built around lighting and blinds, where thermostat, trv and lighting leads with heating and trv units.
Shelly
Who it suits
- Renters and new buyers who want a hub-free start and automations that keep working offline.
- Households already running Alexa, Google or HomeKit, or planning to settle on Matter later.
- Anyone tracking energy use, since energy reporting is standard across the range.
Who should look elsewhere
- SONOFF, if you want thermostatic radiator valves, since thermostat, trv and lighting includes trv and the Shelly range leaves it out.
- Aqara or Lutron, if the same device mix suits you better from another brand, since hub, sensor and lighting, blinds and thermostat cover the same categories.
Current offers
British Gas - Hive - Smart Home & Heating
Not listed
Shelly
Free trial
3 months free on Shelly Smart Control Premium
Free for 3 months, then EUR 3.99/month (monthly plan) or EUR 35.99/year (yearly plan); offer only available if you have not tried Premium before; cancel anytime
Source, checked 30 September 2026
Questions about each
British Gas - Hive - Smart Home & Heating
What does Hive cost to start with?
Entry hardware is priced from £14, which is the lowest figure in the range rather than the cost of a full heating setup. Anything above that, including a hub, sits higher. Hive Plus is a separate subscription at £3.99 a month on top of whatever hardware is bought.
Is there a monthly subscription for Hive Plus?
Hive Plus is listed at £3.99 a month. That is the running cost to weigh after the purchase, and it is separate from the £14 entry hardware price. Buyers who keep a system for years should read the monthly figure as the number that repeats, not the number on the box.
Shelly
What does Shelly hardware cost to start with?
Entry price is €12.90, which covers the cheapest device in the range rather than a bundle. The camera sits higher at €39.90, and the catalogue spans camera and smart lock. Budget for hardware first, then decide whether the cloud extras earn their monthly fee.
Is there a monthly fee or a contract?
The Shelly Smart Control premium plan costs €3.99 a month, and it is optional rather than required. There is no minimum term, since the contract length is 0 months. The Shelly Smart Control standard plan keeps live streaming, motion event recordings and smart notifications at no cost.


